Thursday, September 11, 2008

Issues or Character?

I watched the Republican National Convention this past week. I sat through the speeches of Fred Thompson and Mitt Romney. I heard the shouts of “Drill, baby, drill!” I listened to the hatchet job, the mockery and the smears of Rudy Guliani’s keynote address. I watched and I listened to Gov. Sarah Palin accept her nomination as the first woman VP candidate. I listened to her additional mockery of Barack Obama and his community organizing experience in Chicago. I watched as she brought the house down with cheers and shouting, “USA!” Then finally, the next night I stayed up and watched John McCain give his rousing, inspiring acceptance speech for his presidential candidacy. I must admit I was impressed by his speech and all the other speeches that portrayed John McCain as an American hero. There could be no doubt that years of torture in a Vietnamese POW prison forged the man into a true American hero. I surely do not doubt his love for this country nor his patriotism. I too, rejoiced as the balloons and confetti fell on McCain, Palin and their families to the cheers of the convention crowd. I have to admit that it was a great speech.

Later, in the wake of the Republican National Convention, a wave of hopelessness washed over me. Someone from the McCain campaign stated that the election would be won on personality not the issues. The convention was short on the many issues that confront us but long on the personality of McCain and Palin. How indeed could Obama measure up to a true American hero and a political “maverick?” How could Biden possibly compare with the “gun-toting mother” and governor from the state of Alaska who can “field dress a moose?” As governor and commander–in-chief of the Alaska National Guard sitting on the border with Russia, who could dare to challenge her “foreign affairs experience.” And, do not forget...she is the first woman candidate for VP. McCain and Palin are larger than life personalities to be sure.

In a world where image often trumps substance, I wonder if America will bother to see beyond the Republican distractions, this negative campaign of smears, fear and lies. Will anyone listen to Obama and Biden’s message of hope and “Change We Can Believe In?” Will voters forget the eight long years under this current Republican administration and our nation’s slow, steady slide into the toilet? Will voters remember that John McCain voted with Bush 90% of the time or that he is willing to keep our forces in Iraq 100 years (at a cost of $10 billion a month)? Will post-Hillary women voters understand that Sarah Palin stands for zero exceptions for a woman’s right to choose when it comes to abortion—even in cases of rape, incest or to protect the life of the mother? I wonder if women even noticed there was nothing said by either candidate about protecting equal pay for women for equal work. Ah, but she is the first woman VP candidate ...so who cares. Drill, baby, drill!

I suppose it is more stirring, more patriotic somehow to hear about a brave American soldier and his sacrifice for God and Country than it is to hear about a young man who goes into a blighted inner city neighborhood to try to make changes and bring hope and prosperity to people without hope. Community organizers, like Obama, have worked for things like the 8-hour workday, equality, public transportation, healthcare for kids and safe neighborhoods, but who cares about stuff like that? Sarah and Rudy were right to make fun and mock Obama at the convention, I suppose, after all they do have “executive experience”...and Barack does not. Instead, Barack has had life experience. He has lived with his feet planted in both a black and a white world. He has lived in poverty and wealth. I guess Military service and political office trump all that people-to-people and human interaction stuff. Waving the flag is more exciting than discussing the issues.

Perhaps the McCain camp is correct. This election may be decided on personality rather than the issues. If you throw enough mud and dirty the waters so that the issues and the record of the past eight years are never discussed or debated fairly, then I guess it all does come down to... personality, but I cannot help thinking that character may be the deciding factor. What will be the character of each candidate’s campaign from this point on? More of the same or real change?

FOOD for THOUGHT...

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

I don't think you've been listening carefully to either side. You accuse the Republicans of running a smear campaign, but the Democrats are just as guilty! And as for hatchet jobs and mockery speeches, did you by chance catch Hillary's at the DNC??? McCain's speech was not impressive, he's not that great of a speaker, but his record is impressive.
Do you really want or expect the Republicans to spend their time debating about equal pay for women for equal work just because Palin is on the ticket? Did you hear Hillary whining about that during any of her campaigning? If she had been nominated, would you expect that to be one of her main platforms?
You mentioned Obama's experience as a community organizer, and how he worked for equality, public transportation, safe neighborhoods, and "stuff like that." That's great and all, but you know, we don't live in a bubble. The truth is, he doesn't have the executive or foreign experience to lead this country effectively.
And to clear up a few errors in your post--Sarah Palin is not the first woman VP candidate. Geraldine Ferraro was the first, when she ran on the Democratic ticket with Mondale in 1984. Obama has said that he will keep troops in Iraq as peace keepers, just as we have in North Korea. And may I add, that he has flip flopped on his position of "keep them there vs. pull them out" depending on who is asking him the questions. Sarah Palin does not have a zero tolerance policy when it comes to abortion. You said that she does, even when it comes to protecting the life of the mother, but she has stated that that is one of her exceptions.
You're afraid that the election will be decided by the character of a man who served his country and has the battle scars to prove it, who has the national and foreign political experience, and who's not afraid to stand up to his own party and say, "Enough!". I'm afraid the election will be decided by glitz and glamor and the lacking experience of Hollywood's newest celebrity, who is just not ready to lead.

Anonymous said...

Yup, Geraldine Ferraro has the distinction of first woman VP candidate. Sarah Palin is the first Republican figure head for VP to be poked against the glass ceiling.

Unlike Hillary Clinton, who has spent a career working for womens' rights and issues, Sarah Palin is simply a woman. She probably works hard but we're all trying to figure out what for? McCain pulled a surprise so that everyone would be distracted trying to figure out who she is. But with all due respect, he's old school, simply put. I think SHE will be more than he or his campaign can handle.

As for the issues, let's hope enough people care to think about the consequences. We're at a critical turning point, not just in the US, but in the world.

Eve Ensler, author of the Vagina Monologues, is quoted as writing, "This vote is a vote that will determine the future not just of the U.S., but of the planet. It will determine whether we create policies to save the earth or make it forever uninhabitable for humans. It will determine whether we move towards dialogue and diplomacy in the world or whether we escalate violence through invasion, undermining and attack. It will determine whether we go for oil, strip mining, coal burning or invest our money in alternatives that will free us from dependency and destruction. It will determine if money gets spent on education and healthcare or whether we build more and more methods of killing. It will determine whether America is a free open tolerant society or a closed place of fear, fundamentalism and aggression."

Thanks, Steve, for the Thoughts.